Natalie Firestine
False Sexual Abuse Accuser

Natalie Firestine launched a smear campaign to publicly ruin David Gray’s reputation, a personal vendetta after a 4 month friendship/unreciprocated romance turned sour. She used her legal credentials to recruit victims and co-conspirators with lies and lobbied forum admins to remove David from their groups.

She made the following libelous accusations:

1. Claiming she was pursuing criminal charges as lawyer that she would be reporting to the police and FBI

2. Accused David of being a sexual predator and sexual harasser who preys on girls on enneagram forums

3. Claimed David is a fraud who cons people out of money

4. Claimed David uses fake identities and social media accounts

5. That David is a narcissistic liar, manipulator, NLP brainwasher

6. Claimed that her life and that of others connected to David were in danger

All this after a 4 month friendship that developed after Natalie sought enneagram coaching with David. Although David was upfront about his lack of romantic interest for her, Natalie repeatedly tried to escalate the relationship, eventually pushing for a meetup in Austin, Texas. When David backed out of said meeting, things came to head. After which David made the decision to end their connection permanently. Weeks later, realizing there would be no reconciliation, Natalie threatened and then followed through on attempting to ruin David’s reputation.

Natalie went on an active ‘recruiting’ campaign to defame David, including approaching friends of his with warnings that their lives were in danger by associating with him. She reported him to every internet Facebook group which he was a member. The seriousness of these accusations prompting David’s deletion from all groups.

Natalie contacted the Michigan state police by phone call — they reviewed these accusations and concluded that there was no case and zero crime. She then proceeded to lie by informing everyone that she filed a report with the state police and that they paid a visit to her house. She also claimed she was preparing an investigative report about David Gray she was submitting to the FBI. When a copy of either the police or FBI report was requested, Natalie had no answer.

After reviewing all of Natalie’s ‘evidence’, a major Facebook enneagram group, led by fifteen (15) neutral admins,  unanimously found no grounds for her accusations.  Further still, these same fifteen (15) neutral admins forced her out of the group based on her making what were clearly false accusations, whereas David was reinstated back into said group.

In response, Natalie and a co-conspirator then responded with a more vicious rally of public posts on multiple Facebook groups defaming David and the FB group that reinstated him. (Refer to Evidence Page).

Screenshots below show evidence of Natalie F’s romantic motivation, and threat of revenge after being cut off and ignored:

The intent of this website is to expose Natalie F.’s manipulative liars and false accusations, in an effort to bring an end to her defamatory attacks and harassment. It is unfortunate that Natalie F. co-opted these larger trends of women confronting real abuse in the #metoo movement for her own personal revenge, undermining the credibility of not only the legal profession but of women suffering under real abuse.  Natalie F. used her legal credentials to slander and defame David Gray for months. This conduct is scandalous to the legal profession and we intend to make the necessary formal complaints to ensure Natalie is investigated for ethics violations and disciplinary action is taken.